4PL vs. 3PL

Examining the Difference

Man in warehouse with tablet

Lead logistics providers (LLPs), also referred to as fourth-party logistics (4PL) providers, have a broad role within the supply chain. They assume many of the same roles as third-party logistics (3PL) providers, but have much broader responsibility and accountability in helping the customer reach its strategic goals.

"Accountability and control help differentiate a 3PL from a 4PL," says Andy Moses, senior vice president of sales and solutions for Penske Logistics. "As a 4PL, we become a trusted advisor, and the customer becomes reliant on our data to drive them forward."

When functioning as a 4PL, a logistics service provider becomes a true partner with the customer, working to create a lean, cost-effective supply chain. "The 4PL is the big umbrella. Under the umbrella you have all of the supply chains – transportation, warehouses and anything that is moving," Moses says. "The 4PL manages the big umbrella. That brings more sense of control and ownership."

A 4PL typically directs every moving part within the customer's supply chain and serves as a single point of contact for all parties involved, says Moses. An LLP's role typically includes managing and analyzing large amounts of data, overseeing transportation management, managing other 3PLs and transportation service providers, supervising warehouse operations, or operating any other portion of the supply chain.

"3PLs are very transactional. As a 4PL, you're leading that customer," Moses says, adding that 4PL relationships typically evolve from a 3PL relationship. "The customer becomes reliant on our data to drive them forward. Eventually we are sitting at the table with them, and the operational component is expected."

An LLP works to:

As an LLP, a 4PL uses its high level of visibility, real-time information, communication abilities and broad knowledge to align 3PLs, customers and service providers. A 4PL draws on the data it collects. In addition, it collects, stores and manages data from other supply chain partners. That visibility plays a key role in allowing the customer and 4PL to provide seamless supply chain services, improve customer service, manage exceptions, and remove costs and inefficiencies from the supply chain.

How 3PLs and 4PLs Work Together

When a 3PL transitions to a 4PL, it changes the type of information the provider may access. "I am still a Penske employee, but I am cut off from financial information at Penske because I am working in the customer's best interest," Moses says, adding that a 4PL's goal is to find the best overall transportation solution for its customer. "Penske submits bids, but I am comparing them to bids from their competitors."

Transparency is key for 4PLs that may also function as a 3PL. They must proactively work with customers to demonstrate the checks and balances they put in place, such as creating confidentiality agreements that prohibit the sharing of information and data from the customer's other 3PLs and transportation providers.

Building trust as a 3PL helps smooth the transition to a 4PL function. "You have to build relationships ahead of time, and we do that as a 3PL," Moses says. "Then, as a 4PL, you have to deliver and put it into action."

Andy Moses
Andy Moses is senior vice president of sales and solutions for Penske Logistics. Prior to this role, he was vice president of sales at Penske Truck Leasing. Moses has more than 25 years of experience in the transportation industry, serving in product and sales leadership positions with both Penske Truck Leasing and Rollins Truck Leasing. A Six Sigma Master Black Belt, Moses earned a bachelor's degree in accounting from Brooklyn College and a master's degree from Pennsylvania State University in leadership development.

Use our contact form below to send us your comments and questions.

Contact Details

All fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.

Supply Chain Management

Lead Logistics Provider

Penske understands how to centrally manage and optimize the most complex supply chains.

Consulting Services

Penske understands that you have immediate challenges that require a responsive strategy.